A CBV reader submitted this recent story from NPR that offers up the issue of what demographer Kenneth Johnson refers to as “amenity migrants.” From the story:
More and more Americans are flocking to resort-like cities, places like Flagstaff, Ariz., a quaint college town near the Grand Canyon. For some, it’s a move to paradise. But it can come with a steep price….
“Like many of us, they would say, ‘Boy, when I can, I would really like to live in one of these beautiful, scenic areas,’” Johnson said. “And as they get close to retirement, they can fulfill those wishes” — either in full retirement or by working a more flexible schedule.
Later, the NPR story quotes a lifetime Flagstaff, AZ man as saying,
“People come to the nice little mountain town. So pretty soon, guess what, they want to live here or at least have a part-time home,” Babbitt said. The first thing many of them want to do after arriving, Babbitt said, is to “start to change it into the place where they came from: another park, or some walking trails near their home or, God forbid, a Starbucks.”
In a 2006 Carsey Institute study entitled, Demographic Trends in Rural and Small Town America, Johnson writes of Chaffee County:
Chaffee is not adjacent to a metropolitan area nor does it contain a micropolitan center, but it does have several things going for it. It ranks high on the amenity scale, offers recreational opportunities and is also a retirement destination. From 1990 to 2000, its population grew by 28 percent fueled by a 29 percent net migration gain. This gain was thanks largely to the arrival of newcomers fleeing growing congestion and dense settlement in Denver and elsewhere in the Front Range.
To the NPR story, our CBV reader responds, “The worst thing we can do is try to prevent any growth; second worst is not to anticipate growth, shape it, manage it, and prepare for it.”
You Should Also Check Out This Post:
- Nestlé Waters Unveils Website for Chaffee County Spring Water Project
- National News Hits Home
- Bruce Hayes to play in Buena Vista January 10
- Several January League of Women Voters of Chaffee County meetings focus on water development
- Bucking The Trend
More Active Posts:
- Ideas From Keith Baker On Running For Buena Vista Town Trustee (14)
- What to do about Four Dollar Diesel (7)
- Artisans Abound (7)
- Asking The Wrong Question (6)
- A Clean Trail, A Happy Trail (6)
- Xeriscape does not equal ugly (6)
- New Music Video from Maniacal (6)
- Buena Vista’s ‘Global Café & Market’ Grand Opening (5)
- Rail Service will have to Wait (4)
- Going for the Honey... Shaking the Hive (4)



2 responses so far ↓
1 KBaker // Sep 3, 2008 at 4:32 am
I hope we can learn from the communities who have gone before us. “HIGH COUNTRY NEWS” and others are filled with such stories. We are collectively naive to the point of stupidity if our community thinks we are somehow so special or so clever that we will be unaffected. There are many resources available to help us; there is middle ground. We need Smart Growth and sustainable development. We need jobs and futures for young families. We need Safe Routes to School so children can walk or bike to school. We need trails, walkable, bike-able (and power-chairable) neighborhoods. We need to preserve our open spaces. This is tough because we have inherited 130 years of deferred maintenance and unbuilt infrastructure such as sidewalks. And we need these if not one more person moves here, and we need them yesterday. On the other hand, we have our own coffee shops and local businesses - we DON’T need franchises, big-boxes, and sprawl. We have our own traditions and institutions, and newcomers should assimilate themselves into those - gather in our coffee shops, dine in our restaurants, patronize our businesses, attend our churches, participate in our events - immerse themselves in our community.
2 Todd Herzer // Sep 4, 2008 at 9:17 pm
You’re totally right on Keith, but a good part of my social network is in Salida and there’s a pretty strong sense there that BV is anti-growth and anti progress in general. I’ve heard specific accounts from business owners encountering excessive obstacles trying to get a business launched in this part of the county. Not sure what the facts are, but as they say, “perception is reality”.
Leave a Comment